Nate Eklund on Punching the Shark: Why Teacher Retention Beats Recruitment Every Time

The Ruckus Report

Quick take: Most districts are dumping water into leaky buckets while wondering why they can’t fill them. Nate Eklund shows us why we’ve been solving the wrong problem — and how “punching the shark” creates the workplace conditions that make educators want to stay.

Meet Your Fellow Ruckus Maker

Nate Eklund is the founder and CEO of Vital Network, a national organization focused on improving educator retention and well-being through workplace improvements. A former classroom teacher and author of How Was Your Day at School? Improving Dialogue about Teacher Job Satisfaction, Nate brings deep experience and research-backed insight to the conversation on creating sustainable, joyful workplaces for educators everywhere.

Breaking Down the Old Rules

In this episode, Nate Eklund challenges traditional education paradigms:

Key Insight #1: We Don’t Have a Recruitment Problem — We Have a Retention Problem

  • What’s broken: Districts frantically recruiting new teachers while ignoring why good ones leave
  • The shift: Focus on the “leaky bucket” — in Minnesota, there are more licensed teachers NOT teaching than teaching (enough to fill the Vikings stadium)
  • Impact: When you fix workplace conditions instead of just hiring more people, you solve the math problem at its source

Key Insight #2: Burnout Isn’t a Personal Failing — It’s Environmental

  • What’s broken: Treating burnout as individual weakness (“eat more kale, get more sleep”)
  • The shift: Recognize burnout as systemic depletion that no amount of self-care can overcome — you can’t “kale your way out of your fifth reading curriculum in two years”
  • Impact: Leaders stop blaming teachers and start designing better workplace conditions that prevent burnout

Key Insight #3: There Are Two Versions of Every Educator

  • What’s broken: Accepting that some educators are just “difficult” or “burned out”
  • The shift: Understanding that everyone has a “fired up” version and a “deflated” version — external factors determine which one shows up
  • Impact: Instead of writing people off, leaders create conditions where the best version of every educator can thrive

Quotable Ruckus

“You can dump a lot of water into it and invest a lot of energy getting the water into the bucket, but if the bucket’s leaking, you’ve got a fundamental math problem.”

– Nate Eklund

Your Do School Different Challenge

Ready to implement these ideas? Start here:

  1. Tomorrow: Ask yourself: “What external factors are keeping my best educators from showing up as their best selves?”
  2. This Month: Survey your staff about workplace conditions — not just morale, but actual day-to-day systems and decision-making processes
  3. This Semester: Implement one “Punch the Shark” moment — tackle an uncomfortable workplace issue head-on with your team
target

Get the full episode transcript: here

Follow Nate Eklund: http://www.vitalnetwork.com

twitter

Follow Nate Eklund: Twitter

linkedin

Follow Vital on LinkedIn

If education ain’t a bit disruptive, then what are your students really learning?

This show isn’t about doing school better.

It’s about Doing School Different — and joining a growing movement of bold, creative school leaders who reject legacy models and reimagine what’s possible.

Here are four ways we can help you on your Do School Different journey

notebook

Subscribe to the Free Newsletter

— An opportunity to Do School Different 3x a week. Tools, mindset shifts, and strategies that actually work: ruckusmakers.news

Read Ruckus Makers

— Exclusive content on Substack. Premium leadership insights, AI prompts and custom GPTs, new books before the bookshelf: ruckusmakers.media

 

Join The Ruckus Maker Club

Our private network + workshops, The Automatic School tools, AI Prompt Library, and more:
The Ruckus Maker

 
 

Apply to the Mastermind

— Weekly coaching, peer mentorship, and our proven leadership system (The Ruckus Maker Flywheel) to help you transform your campus:
Apply Now

 
Every tool, community, and coaching program we offer is built to help visionary school leaders play the new game — one where leadership is creative, tech-enabled, and unapologetically student-centered.

The podcast is your starting point. The movement is just getting started.

Today’s RUCKUScast in Partnership with:

IXL: Meet your students where they are and take them where they need to go. Join over 1 million teachers who trust IXL to drive data-informed excellence in their classrooms.
🔍 Learn more
here

Expressability K12: Your inbox isn't a task manager. Your mind isn't for storing mundane processes. It's time to break free. With Expressability K12 Ruckus Makers can prioritize student success by offloading time sucking tasks. Visit Expressability K12 to learn how.
🔍 Learn how here

ODP Business Solutions®: Stop letting compliance kill innovation. Some leaders are transforming their campuses with flexible solutions that actually work for modern learning environments.
🔍 Learn more here

If education ain’t a bit disruptive, then what are your students really learning?

This show isn’t about doing school better.

It’s about Doing School Different — and joining a growing movement of bold, creative school leaders who reject legacy models and reimagine what’s possible.

Here are four ways we can help you on your Do School Different journey

notebook

Subscribe to the Free Newsletter

— An opportunity to Do School Different 3x a week. Tools, mindset shifts, and strategies that actually work: ruckusmakers.news

Read Ruckus Makers

— Exclusive content on Substack. Premium leadership insights, AI prompts and custom GPTs, new books before the bookshelf: ruckusmakers.media

 

Join The Ruckus Maker Club

Our private network + workshops, The Automatic School tools, AI Prompt Library, and more:
The Ruckus Maker

 
 

Apply to the Mastermind

— Weekly coaching, peer mentorship, and our proven leadership system (The Ruckus Maker Flywheel) to help you transform your campus:
Apply Now

 
Every tool, community, and coaching program we offer is built to help visionary school leaders play the new game — one where leadership is creative, tech-enabled, and unapologetically student-centered.

The podcast is your starting point. The movement is just getting started.

Today’s RUCKUScast in Partnership with:

IXL: Meet your students where they are and take them where they need to go. Join over 1 million teachers who trust IXL to drive data-informed excellence in their classrooms.
🔍 Learn more: ixl.com/leaders

The Ruckus Maker Club Community beats compliance every single time. The Ruckus Maker Club is your on demand network of bold school leaders designing the future of education. Join today for $100 a month and get coaching on demand courses, AI prompts and custom GPTs and all our automatic school frameworks and tools within our private digital community.
🔍 Learn more: here

ODP Business Solutions®: Solutions “Our STEAM program is too complicated” = Code for “We’re doing it wrong.” Stop letting fear kill innovation. Some leaders are transforming STEAM with a three-part framework that’s not what you think.
🔍 Get the playbook: ODPbusiness.com/education

© 2025 Twelve Practices LLC | All Rights Reserved
read the Ruckus Maker newsletter